Every January, someone at a small Texas company asks a former employee to ask where to mail their W-2. That question is one among many that come back every year: chasing addresses, sorting out who gets a 1099, settling unused PTO, deciding which old I-9s can go, and gathering records for a workers' comp audit. Each item is a check that got lost in the moment, so it all gets done at once at the end.
The end of year list gets shorter when each item is addressed at the moment it changes. That change is easier at 12 employees than at 30, because every habit a company has gets copied with every hire.
THE YEAR-END HR PROBLEM
Every January, the same work comes back because the underlying records were never updated when things changed.
Table of Contents
The list comes back because it checks, once a year, things that changed all year. Employees moved, subcontractors came and went, people earned and used PTO, and a few left. None of that waited for December, so why wait to address it?
Growth widens the gap. Every new hire adds an address, a W-4, an I-9, and a PTO balance. The company's way of handling each one gets copied along with the paperwork. A process is easiest to change while only a few people are running it the old way, which, for a company still under 30 people, is now.
Addresses get chased in January because the change got made somewhere other than payroll, or nowhere. A W-2 counts as furnished if it's properly addressed and mailed by February 1, 2027, according to the IRS W-2 instructions. The address in payroll is the one that matters. An employee who moved in June and told the crew lead instead of the office gets a W-2 at the old apartment. Then the address gets fixed twice: once this January, and again next January, because it never got fixed in payroll.
Former employees are the hardest to reach. You don't have to wait for them. You can furnish a former employee's W-2 any time after employment ends, as long as it goes out by the deadline. Confirming the mailing address in the exit paperwork settles it on the last day, when the person is still standing in front of you.
FIX THE PROCESS
Confirm the address at exit.
The best time to verify a former employee's mailing address is while that employee is still in front of you.
Decide at the first payment, when a completed W-9 can still be a condition of getting paid. For payments made in 2026, a 1099-NEC is required once a contractor's nonemployee compensation reaches $2,000, up from $600. The form is due to the contractor and the IRS by February 1, 2027, per the IRS 1099 instructions. Asking in January for the taxpayer number of a subcontractor who finished a job in April is a chase.
The same subcontractor list shows up again if you carry a traditional workers' comp policy. A carrier's premium audit typically asks for your subcontractor records, plus certificates of insurance showing each sub's coverage. One list, kept current from the first payment, answers both.
One subcontractor record. Two year-end uses.
TAX REPORTING
The completed W-9 and payment record support 1099 preparation.
WORKERS' COMPENSATION
Subcontractor records and certificates of insurance help support a traditional policy's premium audit.
Unused PTO follows whatever your written policy says. No Texas or federal law requires private employers to provide paid leave or to pay out unused leave. Once paid leave is promised in a written policy, it becomes part of the wage agreement under the Texas Payday Law and is enforced as written. If the policy says nothing about unused leave, that part is not enforceable under the Payday Law.
So the year-end PTO argument is usually a handbook question. If the policy says balances carry over, cap, or reset, payroll's accrual settings should do exactly that. The balances on the last 2026 pay stubs should match what the handbook promises. Where they disagree, settle it before January 1.
YEAR-END RECONCILIATION
Your handbook and your payroll records should agree.
Compare your final December PTO balances against your written carryover, cap, and reset provisions before the year closes.
Keep a former employee's Form I-9 for three years after the date of hire or one year after employment ended, whichever is later, per USCIS. In practice, someone who worked for you less than two years keeps a file for three years from their first day. Someone who worked longer keeps one for a year after their last.
Working that out every December for a drawer of folders is the slow way. A current employee's I-9 stays on file as long as they work for you. Writing the disposal date on the file at termination turns the annual review into reading dates.
Form I-9 retention rule
Keep the form until the later of:
Source: U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS)
A traditional comp policy is priced on the payroll you estimated, then corrected to the payroll you actually ran. The opening premium is an estimate. After the policy period ends, the carrier's premium audit checks actual payroll against records like your quarterly 941s or state unemployment reports. If payroll came in higher than the estimate, the difference is a bill. A crew hired in June that the estimate didn't count comes back as part of that bill, after the policy year is over.
In Texas, most private employers choose whether to carry workers' compensation at all. Those that don't must report to the state that they have no coverage. Lone Star PEO's workers' compensation is pay-as-you-go, with no deposit or audit, so the premium follows each payroll instead of an estimate made a year earlier.
TRADITIONAL POLICY
Estimate now. Reconcile later.
An opening payroll estimate can lead to a later premium adjustment after the policy audit.
LONE STAR PEO
Pay as you go.
Workers' compensation premiums follow payroll as it is processed, with no deposit or audit under the program described.
Lone Star PEO handles each one when it happens. The HR service covers new hire administration and electronic onboarding with I-9 compliance, employee file and form maintenance, a customized employee handbook, and vacation, sick leave, and FMLA tracking. Payroll handles W-4 and W-2 forms. Risk management includes the pay-as-you-go comp coverage described above. An address change or a new subcontractor goes to one person, because every client is assigned its own dedicated payroll specialist as the main contact.
Is your January list the same as last year's?
Start with one record. Compare the PTO balances on your last December pay stubs with what your handbook says they should be. Note every employee where the two disagree. Then talk with Lone Star about which of last January's chores should leave your list for good.
LONE STAR PEO
Make next January's HR list shorter.
Set up a conversation with our team about the recurring payroll, HR, and workers' compensation tasks your business handles every year.
Contact Our TeamWe're not big business. We're your business.
No. No Texas or federal law requires a payout of accrued, unused paid leave. If your written policy promises one, the Texas Payday Law enforces the policy as written.
Three years after the date of hire or one year after employment ends, whichever is later.
By February 1, 2027, the same deadline as current employees. You can furnish it any time after employment ends.
Not for most private employers. An employer that chooses not to carry it must report to the state that it has no coverage. It must also report certain work-related injuries and illnesses to the Division of Workers' Compensation.